Estrogen Dominance: Viruses & Autoimmune Disease

Summary

  • 78% of people with autoimmune disease are women
  • The rate of Hashimoto's thyroiditis is 7X more likely to occur in women than men
  • Lower estrogen increases CD8 lymphocytes, which is central to activation of TH1 inflammatory immunity and viral defense
  • Evidence from mice suggests Estradiol medication can reactivate HSV-1 (herpes simplex-1)
  • EBV (epstein barr virus) can increase aromatization of testosterone into estrogens
  • DIM is both anti-estrogenic as well as anti-viral
  • Numerous botanicals participate in antiviral and anti-estrogenic effects

Sex hormones possess interplay between immunomodulation (1). Studies have shown that CD8 deficiency may underlie numerous autoimmune diseases (3). CD8 is a type of immune protein that binds to MHC class 1 cell surface proteins. Activation of MHC-1 is centrally involved in the cell mediated inflammatory response to antigens such as viruses.

It is suspected that women have a greater predisposition to autoimmune disease because of estrogen’s ability to reduce CD8, thereby reducing the immune system’s ability to fight the infection (2).

Immunologic, inflammatory processes such as cyclooxygenase can effectively upregulate the aromatase enzyme, which converts androgens such as testosterone into estrogens such as estradiol (4).

Viral Associations: Autoimmune & Estrogen Metabolism

Epstein barr virus (EBV) is associated with autoimmune diseases such as Hashimoto’s thyroiditis, Grave’s disease, rheumatoid arthritis, lupus, and Sjögren’s syndrome (5).

Recent studies have found strong associations between EBV and autoimmune thyroid.

A 2015 study found latent membrane protein (LMP1) in follicular epithelial cells and in the infected lymphocytes of 34.5% of Hashimoto’s cases. EBER nuclear expression was found in more than 80% of Hashimoto’s patients and in more than 60% of Grave’s disease patients (6).

Several studies have reported on the effects and associations between viruses and estrogen metabolism.

It has been shown that epstein barr virus is capable of increasing aromatase, favoring elevations in circulating estrogen (7, 8).

A study on mice found that Herpes Simplex 1 (HSV1) can be reactivated with administration of estradiol (10).

Of further interest is that hepatitis B and C has shown to increase the function of CYP1B1, an enzyme that hydroxylates estrone and estradiol into 4OHE1 and 4OHE2, respectively. The 4OH estrogen is a “putative carcinogen” because it can react with DNA and cause unstable DNA adducts to form (9).

This is further evidence to the estrogenic-inducing effects of certain viruses.

Viral & Estrogenic Modulation: Herbs & Nutraceuticals

The nutraceutical compound DIM is used and marketed for anti-estrogenic purposes.

Interestingly, there is evidence that  DIM (di-indolylmethane) not only reduces cell proliferative estrogen metabolites but also is antiviral. DIM was found to increase the antiviral cytokine interferon gamma, while increasing the expression of MHC-1 (11). The same study found that DIM was able to expedite the clearance of reovirus from the gut while simultaneously modulating mucosal IgA. 

The anti-diabetic plant bitter melon (Momordica charantia) has also found to possess estrogen-modulating properties. In rats, bitter melon reduced estrogen levels notably (12). Another study found 4 specific constituents from bitter melon possess significant antagonism of estradiol and both estrogen receptors (13).

Remarkably, bitter melon has also been found to possess anti-viral effects against influenza A, as well as HIV (14, 15).

MAP30, one of the bitter melon constituents has been proposed as effective against active HSV infections as well as HSV viral replication (16).

Artemisinin, a constituent from the plant artemesia possesses numerous antiparasitic, antimicrobial and notable antiviral effects. It has also shown to reduce estrogen receptor function in breast cancer cell line cultures (17).

The relationship between viruses and estrogen metabolism is established. Is it possible that selected nutraceuticals and herbal medicines may effectively be used to attenuate both viral and estrogen effects simultaneously? Clearly more research is warranted.